PBeM / PBMB and Bookeeping

While play testing continues, I as GM am finding the book keeping needed for extended melees to be cumbersome. This not really specific to PUCS, although is some sense PUCs damage by zones does add to the complexity of data management more then I had expected.

Play testing has been performed lately in PBeM (actually PBMB - Play by Message Board), because we have some new parents, many holidays, much travel etc. Since I am GM, our established procedure for game play has made me responsible for everything in the game. Not only do I track the NPCs and build maps, but I also track the PCs and make all the dice rolls. This has been going on for some months now and I have settled into certain patterns that make it a little easier.

I make heavy use of a spreadsheet. You could use Excel or Google Docs, because I do not do anything fancy. I have tab for each PC with all their details. I have a tab for a mission log, where I keep track of each round and events. This has been useful because in visiting the game only a few minutes a day, I can not remember all that has gone on, but in a few seconds I can refresh myself. Also elements of this log end up as posts on the Message board.

I also do all the dice rolling in the spreadsheet. Some may not prefer that, that is fine, but it works really well for me as the dice are not always handy when I need a roll or three. The dice rolling has become more elaborate over the last two months. I do not use a script /r 3d6+. Rather I have a dozen or so common PUCS rolls written in simple formulas, that I can recalculate with a keystroke. It has become so fast that I can process the dice rolling part of melee in a few seconds.

For the map, I still use MapTool. This tool works really well for me and is indispensable for PBeM/PBMB. I take a screen shot (from the tool) and upload the image to http://flickr.com/ If this were PBeM I could just attach the images in each email, but on the message board, its easier (for me at least) to link to an image. Although our board also supports attachments, I prefer the Flickr links. The Flickr links are scalable, players can really zoom and examine the map if they choose too. Furthermore since I keep the images in set for the campaign, players can easily review all the images directly in flickr (for example: http://flickr.com/photos/8832225@N08/sets/72157604384209063/ ). Naturally they can review them on the message board also. In the end this give GMs and Players more options. More options with no additional effort, can not be a bad thing. If you are not familiar with flickr, I use a free account which is limited to 100MB of uploads per month. I have never even come close to that limit yet. You can also have a paid account but I have yet to need one.

Playtesting Continues!

It has been a quiet month at least with regard to blog posting. However play testing has been proceeding at a furious pace. This is a lot of fun, because so far at least, there has been very little debate about the rules. The game is just flowing along and isn't that point anyway?

What is surprising to me is that the players for the most part remain in a D20 psychology about melee. This is creating additional risk for each character and is giving their opponents (run by GM) an advantage. However it has been a lot of fun and no characters have died and early on at least there was a good deal of maneuvering going on. Some missile weapons and some spell casting all to limited effect.

I would like to think that the good flow and lack of debate implies that rules are gaining some polish. It may be that testers are holding there tongues until the test is complete and they can comment on the total result rather some specific nuance here or there.

Below are some screen shots of melee. 3 PCs assaulting a hill against a force of unknown strength. The PCs played it pretty smart. Split the defenders fire, made good use of spells, and then heavy melee ensued. If they made one mistake, it would be that they let themselves get split up. They are out numbered and would be stronger if the party remained together.

What I have found most interesting is that the PCs, should already have been defeated. There has been some lucky rolling here and there, but on balance they are doing well. The melee is not yet complete, so I can't say they will be victorious, they do at least at this moment have equal odds.

Screen Shots:



Here the party came under missile fire from the rocks at the top of the map. One PC took cover and intended to return fire with a bow. The other 2 PCS charged up the hill side at angle. The effect was to divide the missile fire. As it turned out there was only 1 bow firing on them, that bowmen kept at the PC who took cover. As it turns out, that is because the bowmen never had a field of view of the other 2 PCS.



The PC taking cover, has a few more close calls with incoming arrow, but is never able to spot the shooter. He figures the general area of the shooter, inside deep shadow on the rock face and casts a sleep spell on that location. He has no idea if he got the shooter or not. The other 2 PCs continue on up the hill, but realize as they draw closer that the rock is rimmed by a dense brier. They see no way to approach the rock where the shooter likely is.



The charging PCs fall into prone positions with some cover and scan the brier for a path. While doing so they spot a defender laying prone on the rocks. They also spot a group of 4 defenders approaching from the West and heading towards their lone companion. They shout warnings.



The defenders charge continues, some spells are exchanged and one defender drops. At the same time, a cut in the brier is found and a PC blitz into it. With 3 warriors coming fast, the lone PC decides to make a break for his companions.



The break is well timed, and he stays out ahead of them. Meanwhile one PC melee's in the brier cut while the 3rd moves towards to help against the defenders from the West.



Here the action has effectively devolved into melee. The party has done well against an opponent with greater number and more skill. I am a little disappointed that party has not made better use of their capacity for movement as a defense. Still they have done well and its a been a fun so far!

BTW all screen shots done with Maptool

This has been a slow month

While this month has been slow.  Play testing has been a lot of fun.  The new magic rules are very interesting tactically.  Balance wise, no one is quite certain where it should go.  It could easily become a sort of Harry Potter style melee where everyone uses magic, because it is so much more powerful then melee weapons alone.  However none of the play testers nor designers really want that to happen.

One obvious difference is that melee which was already more hazardous then D20 variants, really requires tactical thinking.  If you just stand toe to toe, and your opponent takes advantage of movement rules your not going to do well.  In short there is a lot more moving around in melee then anyone really expected.

Recently in play testing a low power party encountered a giant crocodile.   The monster ambushed the party at a broken down bridge, where the party had little freedom of movement.  The crocodile attacked, nearly killed a horse and was trying to drag it away.  The party went after the crocodile, but the crocodile retreated, then ambushed again and nearly killed a party member.  The party hacked away at the beast but to little effect.  Finally the character who was ambushed and being crushed by the crocodile, successfully put the beast  to sleep with a spell.  However the spell was an area of effect spell.  They were all of them clustered together, and half the rest of the party went down too.   It was tremendous fun!  Read some detail about it here.

Otherwise, rules review is proceeding more slowly then anyone would like.  Hopefully DRAFT2 by the end of the month.

Axis and Allies

This is unrelated to PUCS development but it was so cool I had to mention it. My friend has been laid up after some surgery earlier this month. We have been play Axis and Allies via Map Tool and its been a lot of fun so far. Below are some screen shots.

The Russian Front

The Battle Board

The Complete Map

I really remain impressed with this FREE, flexible and easy to use application from the good folks over at http://www.rptools.net. I eagerly await their 1.3 release coming out of BETA sometime this year.

Dealing with light in game play

Recently I played in a very spirited campaign. All involved were experienced and the characters had been in use off and on for many years. However this time the campaign was played using a VGT (Virtual Game Table) called Maptool for the first time. There was a noticeable change in player behavior and this was completely due to the lack of light which Maptool does an excellent job of representing.

Traditionally on the table top, the map is revealed in bit and pieces as the characters "See" more, using either torches, lanterns, light spells or whatever. We more or less took the light for granted and it rarely slowed the pace of the party in exploration or melee. In fact rarely did light effect player behavior or impact die rolls. This was really a convenience for both GM and the players. It had been going on for so long that none of us even thought it about it any longer.

However in last weekends play something amazing happened. The players were, for lack of better word, Timid! In more then one example the strong fighter type would blitz after a foe and stop. Thats right STOP at the edge of the light. I can't recall that ever happening before. Furthermore our sources of light were limited to certain characters and the other characters tended to bunch up, bathing in the warm glow of thelight. Furthermore in a large and dark cavern. The characters were easy targets for foes outside the light with melee weapons. This is new behavior and really added to the fun!

None of this really has anything to do with developing a RPG, but it was such a powerful and positive experience I had to share the effect. I recommend that if you have not used a VGT you try one out sometime soon. We used Maptool which is free, works on multiple platforms, is easy to install, and not too difficult to learn to use.